
On November 3rd, two of my Top Five artists – Weezer and Foo Fighters – released an album. I was in heaven. At least unit they came out; then I was disappointed.
Actually, disappointed is a strong word. I was… hit by reality.
In my opinion, Foo Fighters have never made a bad song. I have them ALL. Every song ever recorded practically anywhere is on my playlist somewhere. Every one is a gem.
In my opinion Weezer is one of the most underrated bands of all time. Every album contains some of the catchiest, original, diverse songs around. Obviously their three self-titled albums are the best, but even their often-lambasted Pinkerton contains some amazingly simple tunes.
And now the reality:

Most of these are demos. They mostly kick ass.
Every song that Foo Fighters release is amazing. I can’t think of one single that isn’t astounding. Even their unpopular tracks – “Cold Day in the Sun”, “Alone + Easy Target” – are spectacular. However, the majority of songs that I have found from them – demos, live tracks, and unreleased material – could be spectacular. What I mean is, if they ever make an album of remastered b-sides, it’d go platinum; but as the tracks stand, there’s a reason they didn’t make the album cut. So it is with their new song “Word Forward.”
Every album that Weezer makes is amazing. I can’t think of any album that I haven’t listened to dozens of times through. There are songs on every album, however, that I jump past. Even their seminal Blue Album has a song or two that just don’t seem good enough (“Holiday” jumps to mind). I seem to forget this whenever they come out with something new.
The new self-titled Foo Fighters greatest hits album contains one song I didn’t have – it sounds exactly like a demo that could kick ass. The new Weezer album, Raditude (named by Rainn Wilson, oddly enough) contains some of the catchiest, original, diverse songs around, but it contains a few that just aren’t good enough.
Greatest Hits: 4 stars if I didn’t already have five different recordings of every song. Since I do, 2 stars for the new song.
Raditude: Like all of Weezer’s albums, 3 stars for the album, 5 stars for a select few songs.
On a side-note, I think I would rather these bands come out with something annually as they’ve been doing and throw in some crappy songs as opposed to artists who release a new album twice a decade (you reading this, Reznor?).